Overrated or Underrated

scotland gordon strachan 2

Overrated or Underrated: Gordon Strachan (Scotland)

For the ninth straight tournament Scotland will be on the outside looking in following failure to qualify for Euro 2016 under Gordon Strachan. It is only right we ask whether the current Scotland boss is overrated or underrated.

Read More

fletcher

Overrated or underrated: Steven Fletcher (Scotland)

After Scotland’s disastrous double-header we had to pick out a player for the Overrated or Underrated treatment. And no starter is being discussed more at the moment than the Sunderland striker.

Read More

celtic scott allan2

Overrated or underrated: Scott Allan (Celtic)

The first edition of Overrated or Underrated in the 2015/16 campaign had to be about the man everyone’s still talking about.

Read More

exc-5525ce58e4b0d00c79e75fde

Danny Wilson

CRAIG ANDERSON When Danny Wilson made his debut for Rangers, I bought into the hype about him. Rangers were the reigning league champions at the time, and were a club not exactly renowned for giving youth a chance, so a 17-year old centre-back who managed to force his way into the team must have been […]

Read More

exc-54e5e341e4b082ee2056339c

Mark Reynolds

THE question is simple. Is Aberdeen centre back Mark Reynolds generally overrated or underrated as a footballer by his peers, coaches, fans and the media? The guys at The Terrace Scottish Football Podcast give their answer. JOEL SKED Since making the centre back position a permanent role in the Aberdeen defence, Mark Reynolds has for me developed […]

Read More

exc-54e5e140e4b06fd48ba0ce8b

Gary Mackay-Steven

THE question is simple. Is Dundee United winger Gary Mackay-Steven generally overrated or underrated as a footballer by his peers, coaches, fans and the media? The guys at The Terrace Scottish Football Podcast give their answer.* *written a couple of months before GMS’s move to Celtic. JOEL SKED Gary Mackay-Steven has had an unusual path to Dundee […]

Read More

exc-53fc9a77e4b00e21d4f14274

Paul Hanlon

THE question is simple. Is Hibernian centre back Paul Hanlon generally overrated or underrated as a footballer by his peers, coaches, fans and the media? There’s no doubt that Hanlon has failed to live up to the initial hype, but he’s had the ignominy of playing for a team which has been lambasted from all […]

Read More

exc-53f5e62be4b0da8664b10309

Fraser Forster

The first of a new weekly feature The Terrace Scottish Football Podcast running in association with Scotsman.com. Since he’s just been sold for a huge transfer fee, we may as well start with former Celtic hero Fraser Forster. Is he overrated or underrated? CRAIG ANDERSON In his first season at Celtic I was unconvinced by Forster. […]

Read More

Subscribe to Podcast